Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player


Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

 
Oregon Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) is proposing changes to its Industrial Stormwater General Permits Nos. 1200-Z and 1200-COLS. The proposed permits replace the 1200-COLS permit, effective September 1, 2006, and the 1200-Z permit, effective July 1, 2007. DEQ is also proposing the 1200-ZN permit for facilities that do not have a 1200-Z permit and apply for the permit between September 1st and June 30th.

The Industrial Stormwater General Permit No. 1200-Z (1200-Z permit) covers a broad range of industry throughout Oregon that discharge stormwater to rivers, streams and other surface waters. The Industrial Stormwater General Permit No. 1200-COLS (1200-COLS permit) covers industries that discharge to the Columbia Slough Watershed in the Portland metro area. There are about 773 facilities registered under the 1200-Z permit and 139 facilities registered under the1200-COLS permit.

These permits regulate various pollutants from industrial activities that may be discharged in stormwater during rain and snow events. The stormwater from industrial activities discharges to rivers and streams, or to storm drains that eventually discharge to rivers and streams. Stormwater often contains pollutants that may harm aquatic life and their habitat. The permits require facilities to implement best management practices to reduce pollutants in stormwater and to meet benchmarks that measure the success of these management practices.

These permits expire every five years. DEQ renewed the 1200-Z permit in 2002 and 2007. The current 1200-Z permit became effective on July 1, 2007 and expires on June 30, 2012. DEQ renewed the 1200-COLS permit in 2006. The current 1200-COLS permit became effective on September 1, 2006 and expires on August 31, 2011.


In 2007 and 2008, two environmental advocacy groups, Northwest Environmental Defense Center (NEDC) and Columbia Riverkeeper, challenged the current permits’ validity under the Federal Clean Water Act. DEQ settled the legal challenge and as part of the settlement agreement agreed to revise the permits.(1) Under the settlement agreement, DEQ agreed to:

• Issue new permits based on the EPA Multi-Sector General Permit (EPA’s permit) for industrial stormwater discharges issued in September 2008.

• Convene an advisory committee to provide input on the proposed changes to the permits. Specifically, DEQ agreed to discuss the following issues with the committee:

-Evaluate whether facilities should monitor their discharge at least once a year (i.e., not allowing a monitoring waiver for facilities that consistently meet benchmarks).
- Evaluate the consequences for not meeting benchmarks.
- Evaluate increasing monitoring to characterize the pollutants in industrial stormwater discharges.

• Retain the public notice and comment provisions in the current Oregon permits and continue to review stormwater pollution control plans.

In May 2010, DEQ and NEDC and Columbia Riverkeeper amended the settlement agreement to provide additional time for DEQ to develop water quality-based metals benchmarks for copper, lead, and zinc.(2)

In June 2009, DEQ convened an advisory committee comprised of representatives of affected industries, small businesses, municipalities, environmental groups and stormwater consultants. The committee met sixteen times from June 2009 to April 2011 and provided input to DEQ on the proposed changes to the permits. DEQ is proposing significant changes to the permits. DEQ made these changes based on settlement agreements with NEDC and Columbia Riverkeeper, advisory committee input and the evaluation of the federal EPA MSGP permit. These changes include the following:

• Significantly lowering the metals benchmarks for copper, lead and zinc based on an evaluation of the state’s waters.
• Requiring certain industries that are not consistently achieving the benchmarks to hire a professional engineer or certified engineering geologist to design their stormwater plan and identify best available technologies to reduce pollutants.
• Adding more pollutant monitoring:

- Industries that discharge to impaired waters that are not meeting the state water quality standards will monitor for impairment pollutants on DEQ’s 303(d) list and take corrective actions if these pollutants are present in their discharge.

- Industries will monitor for Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) and a broader suite of metals (cadmium, chromium and nickel) to determine if they are present in industrial stormwater. Certain industries will also monitor for industry specific benchmarks.
• Adding precision to sample collection requirements. If possible, industries will collect grab composite samples, sample during first rain event after September 1st and within first 12 hours of each storm (maximum of four events per year).
• Improving efficiency and effectiveness in the reporting process. This includes specifying events which require submission of revised stormwater plans.



The proposed permits contain requirements for new and existing discharges to impaired waters with or without EPA approved TMDLs.
• New dischargers are only eligible for discharge authorization if they demonstrate (and document) that there is either no exposure of stormwater to the pollutant for which the water is impaired, or the impairment pollutant is not present at the facility, or that the discharge is not expected to cause or contribute to a water quality standards exceedance.

• For new and existing discharges to impaired waters with EPA approved TMDLs, DEQ will presume that compliance with the terms and conditions of the permit complies with the TMDL unless a Waste Load Allocation (WLA) is established for industrial stormwater discharges. DEQ conducted a review on Oregon’s TMDLs to determine if stormwater discharges were considered in the source assessment of the TMDL and whether stormwater was identified as a significant source.(3) During source assessment, the TMDL program evaluates the significant sources of the impairment. Typically, stormwater is not considered a significant source because of the pollutant/impairment (for example, temperature) the TMDL is addressing. Most TMDLs either do not mention stormwater or specifically state that stormwater is not considered a significant source of the impairment.

• If a WLA is established, DEQ will evaluate whether additional requirements are necessary to ensure the discharge is consistent with the TMDL. If the water is impaired but there is no completed TMDL, the discharger is required to control its discharge as necessary to meet applicable water quality standards and to conduct routine monitoring for the pollutants for which the waterbody is impaired.
DEQ is proposing significantly lower metals benchmarks for copper, lead and zinc. The lead and zinc benchmark values were determined using risk-based modeling with conservative inputs for parameters such as hardness and metals concentrations in the receiving waters. DEQ used a technology-based approach to determine the proposed copper benchmark because results of risk-based modeling yielded copper benchmark values that were very low and would not be regularly achieved by active treatment.

TABLE OF DEQ's PROPPOSED BENCHMARKS

The industrial stormwater general permits are based on an adaptive management approach where permit registrants monitor their stormwater discharge, evaluate the effectiveness of their control measures, and take corrective actions to ensure they are controlling the industrial pollutants that are exposed to stormwater to achieve the benchmarks in the permit. DEQ evaluated the corrective action requirements in the current permits and as part of the settlement agreement agreed to seek feedback from the advisory committee on developing permit requirements for facilities that repeatedly fail to meet benchmarks. Based on these discussion and evaluations, DEQ is proposing changes to the corrective action requirements in the
permit.
THE PROPOSED PERMITS INCLUDE THE NEW CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIREMENTS THAT:
• Focus on those facilities that consistently fail to meet the statewide benchmarks (Tier II) and require that these facilities install the best available technology to reduce the pollutants below benchmarks. These facilities must hire a licensed professional engineer or certified engineering geologist to add scrutiny to the selection of control measures to address the pollutants of concern and revise the SWPCPs.

• Clarify the timeline and corrective actions facilities must take if they exceed benchmarks.

• Provide flexibility for facilities to evaluate all available control measures such as operational, structural or treatment BMPs to address the pollutants of concern. Facilities should first consider source control measures, if possible, before implementing more resource intensive BMPs such as installing a treatment system.• Promote the use of volume reduction measures such as low impact development practices to reduce stormwater flow and control the mass load of pollutants that enter the receiving stream.

• Promote innovations in stormwater management.

• Improve the quality of industrial stormwater discharge over time.
DEQ is proposing that a more rigorous approach for facilities that routinely exceed the statewide benchmarks in the proposed permits. These facilities must meet the Tier II corrective action requirements. To provide added scrutiny of the BMPs needed to control the pollutant(s) that are above the benchmark(s), DEQ is proposing a licensed professional engineer or certified engineering geologist conduct a comprehensive review of control measures that are technologically available and economically achievable in light of best industry practice. The goal of these added controls is to eliminate or reduce the pollutant concentration(s) in future discharges below the benchmarks in new permits. The updated SWPCP will identify the selected control measures and provide the rationale and analysis supporting that the selected control measures are technologically available and economically achievable in light of best industry practice in the engineering report. DEQ is proposing that these facilities implement the selected BMPs within 18 months.

DEQ is proposing to the following changes to the monitoring requirements:

• Types of pollutants monitored: Expanding the number of pollutant parameters that permit registrants must monitor in stormwater runoff. In addition to the statewide benchmarks retained from the current permit, certain registrants must monitor pollutants based on their industrial sector and impairment pollutants based on discharges to impaired waterbodies. DEQ is also proposing that facilities monitor additional pollutants (PAHs, chromium, nickel and cadmium) to identify if these pollutant sources are commonly present in industrial stormwater and to inform future permit development.

• Timing of sample collection: If practicable, facilities must collect a seasonal first flush sample of the “first fall storm event” after September 1 that produces a discharge from the facility. Also, if practicable, facilities are also required to collect samples within the first twelve hours
of the storm event.

• Sampling Method: For the first two years of coverage under the permit, grab composite sampling will be used to collect samples if practicable. Facilities will collect three grab samples and combine them into one sample that is then analyzed by the laboratory. Utilizing the grab composite monitoring method will yield more representative analytical results than individual
grab sampling.

The public comment period closed on June 16, 2011. DEQ plans to issue these permits by September 1, 2011. The 1200-COLS permit will become effective on September 1, 2011. The 1200-Z permit will be become effective on July 1, 2012. Once the permits are issued, there will be a period of time where facilities will renew their coverage under the new permits. The draft permits and the factsheet that explains the changes to the permits are located on DEQ’s website at http://www.deq.state.or.us/wq/stormwater/industrial.htm.

For Additional Information: Jenine Camilleri, DEQ Stormwater Coordinator, 503/ 229-6775.



by Jenine Camilleri, DEQ Stormwater Coordinator (Portland)
Issue #467 / June 2011



Bookmark and Share

Jenine Camilleri is a Stormwater Coordinator for Oregon Department of Environmental Quality working out of the Headquarters office in Portland, Oregon. She started in this position in January 2006. She has been working on the revisions to the NPDES Industrial Stormwater General Permits. She has worked for DEQ since 2000. She worked for six years as an Environmental Law Specialist in DEQ’s Office of Compliance and Enforcement. She received a JD from Northwestern School of Law at Lewis and Clark College in Portland, Oregon and a BS in Environmental Policy Studies at Michigan State University.

Oregon Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ
Industrial Stormwater General Permits Nos. 1200-Z and 1200-COLS
Columbia Riverkeeper
Northwest Environmental Defense Center (NEDC)

The Oregon Insider is a "subscriber-only" newsletter. Please sign in, or subscribe.

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

INSIDER NEWS I ENVIRO-BRIEFS I RESOURCE CENTER I CALENDAR & EVENTS I SUBSCRIBE NOW I MEMBER LOGIN I ABOUT / CONTACT I HOME

The Oregon Insider
PO Box 21040 Eugene, Oregon 97402
Phone: 541.729.1546
Jeff B. Knebel / Managing Editor
editor@theoregoninsider.com

Copyright 2011, The Oregon Insider. All Rights Reserved.